The Daily News

FEATURED HEADLINE

The Story of the Freedom-of-Information Requests for Doug Gilchrist’s Pay Records

Peter Blackwell filed freedom-of-information requests with the City of Kelowna for Doug Gilchrist’s employment contract and all amendments, the market surveys used to set his compensation, the closed-meeting records on his performance review and pay, and the internal emails that authorized the increases.

On FOI2026-112 the City ran the request to the end of the statutory window. It then sent a letter asking for an extension. It stated the records would be ready as soon as possible. After that it sent another letter demanding a $2,000 deposit before it would finish the work. When half the package arrived on 13 November 2026 it was an 80-page file that was heavily redacted. The City left its own internal HR emails readable. Those emails list the successive authorized amounts: the 2018 contract started at $247,487 plus a $500 monthly vehicle allowance; the 2023 authorization went to $324,253 with the vehicle allowance raised to $870 a month; 2024 went to $341,158; 2025 went to $358,251.68. The Korn Ferry survey pages, the closed-meeting notes, the motion, and the vote count were blacked out. The public already knew the final yearly totals from the SOFI reports. The new piece was the City’s own paper trail authorizing the steps in between, set against the blacked-out pages that were supposed to explain them.

Names that appear in the open portions of the package and in the process include Doug Gilchrist, Mayor Tom Dyas, City Clerk Laura Bentley, and Stu Leatherdale, who sent comparator information to the Audit Committee. The Audit Committee reviews the City Manager’s performance before it goes to full Council. Those closed-meeting records stayed redacted.

A separate request, FOI2026-116, was also filed. The City demanded a deposit on that file. When the deposit was not received, the Office of the City Clerk sent a letter stating the request was considered abandoned and the file was closed. No records were released.

Anyone can file the same request. Email cityclerk@kelowna.ca with your name and address and ask for Doug Gilchrist’s employment contract and all amendments, all salary and vehicle-allowance increases, all Korn Ferry or other market surveys used for his compensation, all closed-meeting agendas, minutes, motions and votes on his performance review and pay from 2018 to present, and all internal payroll authorization emails or memos. Demand a response within the statutory timelines. The City can still charge a fee and can still black out pages. If you receive a deposit demand or a heavily redacted package, you have 30 days to ask the Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner to review the fee or the redactions.

The documents the City released under FOI2026-112, including the internal HR emails that list the successive amounts and the blacked-out pages that surround them, are available for download at douggilchrist.ca. The sequence on these files was: requests filed; City ran one file to the end of the window, asked for an extension, said the records would be ready as soon as possible, then demanded $2,000 and released a package in which the internal instructions to raise the pay stayed visible while the justification and the vote stayed hidden; on the second file the City demanded a deposit and closed the file when it was not paid. That is the record.

Full FOI Record and Content Report – City of Kelowna – Doug Gilchrist Compensation Files

This report sets out every FOI interaction and every piece of content established in the materials reviewed in this conversation. It is limited to what the records and correspondence actually show. Exact calendar dates for intermediate letters (extension request, deposit demand) are not extracted in the text history; the only firm date attached to a released package is 13 November 2026 for FOI2026-112.

Requests Filed

Peter Blackwell filed freedom-of-information requests with the City of Kelowna seeking Doug Gilchrist’s employment contract and all amendments, the market surveys (Korn Ferry and any others) used to set his compensation, the closed-meeting agendas, minutes, motions and votes relating to his performance review and pay, and the internal HR or payroll authorization emails and memos that implemented the increases, covering the period from 2018 to the present.

FOI2026-112 – Sequence and Release

On FOI2026-112 the City ran the request to the end of the statutory response window. It then requested an extension. It stated that the records would be ready as soon as possible. After that it issued a demand for a $2,000 deposit before it would complete the processing. The package was released on 13 November 2026. It consisted of an 80-page file that was heavily redacted under multiple sections of the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act (including provisions covering advice to Council, closed-meeting records, third-party information, and related exceptions).

What Remained Readable in FOI2026-112

Pages 1–6 contained the 2018 employment contract. It started Gilchrist at $247,487 per year plus a $500 monthly vehicle allowance.

Pages 78–80 contained internal HR emails that listed the successive authorized increases:

•  2023: $324,253, with the vehicle allowance raised to $870 a month.

•  2024: $341,158.

•  2025: $358,251.68.

These internal authorization emails were not previously public. The final yearly totals that appear in the City’s annual SOFI reports were already known. The new information was the City’s own paper trail showing the intermediate authorized steps.

What Was Blacked Out in FOI2026-112

The Korn Ferry market-survey section was redacted. The closed-meeting notes, the motion, the vote count, and the written justification for the increases were redacted. Open council minutes included in the package list who was present when meetings were closed for items that included the City Manager Performance Review. The actual closed-meeting discussion, resolution, and vote were blacked out. A majority of those present is required to pass a resolution. The package does not show the split.

Names Appearing in the Open Portions and Process

Doug Gilchrist (City Manager).

Tom Dyas (Mayor).

Laura Bentley (City Clerk, FOI process).

Stu Leatherdale (General Manager, People and Protective Services), who sent comparator information to the Audit Committee.

The Audit Committee is the Council body that reviews the City Manager’s performance and the management/exempt staff pay policy before the matter goes to full Council. Those closed-meeting records stayed redacted.

FOI2026-116 – Closure

A separate request, FOI2026-116, was also filed. The City issued a deposit demand for that file. The letter from the Office of the City Clerk (cityclerk@kelowna.ca) states that because the deposit for FOI2026-116 was not received, the City is considering the request abandoned and is closing the file. No responsive records were released on that file.

FIPPA Process That Applied

Under the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act a public body can charge fees for locating, retrieving, and preparing records and can require a deposit before it does the work (section 75). Paying a deposit does not guarantee unredacted records. The City can still sever information under the listed exceptions after the search is complete. Each request is separate. If a large number of identical requests arrive at the same time, the City can apply under section 43 for permission to treat them as a single matter or to disregard a systematic campaign of interference.

The sequence on FOI2026-112 was: request filed; City ran to the end of the window; City requested an extension and stated the records would be ready as soon as possible; City demanded a $2,000 deposit; City released an 80-page package on 13 November 2026 in which the internal HR emails listing the successive authorized amounts remained readable while the surrounding justification, the Korn Ferry material, the closed-meeting notes, the motion, and the vote count were blacked out. On FOI2026-116 the City demanded a deposit and, when it was not received, closed the file as abandoned.

What the Public Still Does Not Have:

The Korn Ferry survey numbers.

The closed-meeting discussion and written justification for the increases.

The motion and the vote count (whether the increases passed 5-4, 6-3, 7-2, or any other split).

Any record showing how many councillors supported or opposed the raises.

The raises themselves are visible in the City’s own internal emails. The reasons and the vote are not. That is the record the City produced after the extension, the statement that the records would be ready as soon as possible, and the $2,000 deposit demand on FOI2026-112, and after the deposit demand and file closure on FOI2026-116.

Anyone can file the same request by emailing cityclerk@kelowna.ca with their name and address and asking for the contract and amendments, all salary and vehicle-allowance increases, all market surveys, all closed-meeting records on the performance review and pay, and all internal authorization emails from 2018 to present. The City can still issue a fee estimate and can still redact. A requester who receives a deposit demand or a heavily redacted package has 30 days to ask the Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner to review the fee or the severing.

These are four separate Freedom of Information (FOI) requests under B.C.’s Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act.

They seek specific public records from the City of Kelowna about City Manager Doug Gilchrist’s compensation, potential conflicts involving real estate, a major $27.8 million land deal, and related housing/rail matters plus his expenses. The City is required to respond within 30 business days and must cite specific legal sections if it withholds anything. Missed deadlines count as a refusal and can be appealed to the Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner.

The requests are detailed because the public only sees high-level totals (such as salary on the annual Statement of Financial Information). The goal is the underlying documents that show how decisions were made, who authorized them, and whether rules on conflicts or value-for-money were followed. Silence or delay on these kinds of requests is itself a transparency problem with taxpayer money.

1. City Manager pay, contract, raises, and who authorized them

What is being asked: The full employment contract and every amendment or salary schedule from 2022–2025 that changed Doug Gilchrist’s pay; the management pay-band policy and any market surveys or consultant reviews (such as Korn Ferry) used to adjust bands in 2023–2025, plus any memo applying them to the City Manager role; closed-meeting records from Council that dealt with his compensation or performance (including the resolution that closed the meeting and any outcome); and the name and title of the person who actually authorized the payroll rate change each year.

Why it matters and what it could show: Public records show his pay rose sharply after he became City Manager (roughly from the mid-$200,000s range in earlier years to the mid-to-high $300,000s more recently, plus expenses). The public is entitled to know whether the increases were ordinary grid steps, documented market adjustments, performance bonuses, or something else—and whether Council (as the employer) properly approved them or whether day-to-day payroll changes were signed off by someone else. Possible issues include poorly documented or unjustified increases, raises driven by internal staff rather than independent Council oversight, or a lack of clear public accountability for a top unelected official’s compensation in a city the size of Kelowna.

2. Stephanie Gilchrist PREC / Coldwell Banker Horizon and City land or commissions

What is being asked: All City land sales, purchases, leases, licences, or listings (2019 onward) where a commission, referral fee, or success fee was paid, showing the brokerage or licensee, property, date, amount, and payee; communications between City staff (including the City Manager) and Stephanie Gilchrist, her Personal Real Estate Corporation, or Coldwell Banker Horizon about civic land, buildings, or developers with active City files; any conflict-of-interest disclosures, recusals, screening notes, or legal opinions mentioning the City Manager’s household or a realtor in that household in connection with land, planning, or procurement; preferred or listing-agent lists used by the City for surplus property; and records showing who authorized any real-estate commission payments and the amounts.

Why it matters and what it could show: Stephanie Gilchrist is a licensed realtor with Coldwell Banker Horizon in Kelowna. The request tests whether her business (or the household) has touched City real-estate transactions, commissions, or listings while Doug Gilchrist has been in a senior real-estate and City Manager role. Possible issues include undisclosed conflicts, commissions or fees flowing to a household member on City deals, preferred-agent status that creates an appearance of favoritism, or missing recusal or screening records. Even the absence of such records after a proper search is relevant information the public is entitled to see.

3. The $27.8 million Westcorp waterfront purchase, management arrangements, and related advisors

What is being asked: The purchase agreement and amendments for 289 Queensway, 1440–1460 Pandosy, and the Kelowna Marina / 210 Bernard (including the $27.8 million price and any allocations); appraisals, assessments, and the staff report recommending the price; any management or operating agreement with Westcorp, related companies, or individuals (term, fee, who signed); the engagement of Avington Financial Limited (mandate, fees, success fee, reports delivered); Municipal Finance Authority / borrowing staff reports and the interest-only and principal terms; emails, calendars, and meeting notes among specified people (including Doug Gilchrist, the Mayor, Westcorp figures, and Avington) about the acquisition or a hotel partner; and any recusal by the City Manager on the file.

Why it matters and what it could show: This is described as one of the City’s largest property acquisitions. The City bought a long-stalled hotel site (assessed higher than the purchase price in some reports), an office building, and the marina from Westcorp, borrowed the money through the Municipal Finance Authority, and left Westcorp managing the revenue-producing assets in the interim while seeking a hotel partner (later identified as involving Marriott). Possible issues include whether the price was supported by independent appraisals, whether management fees or ongoing roles create conflicts or soft benefits for the seller, whether the City Manager or others properly disclosed or recused from decisions involving parties with ongoing relationships, and whether the closed process and financing terms were fully documented for public scrutiny.

4. Rail corridor / Rail Trail lands, Pleasantvale / Now Canada housing, and City Manager expenses

What is being asked: Purchase or acquisition records for the rail corridor / Rail Trail lands the City has called a legacy acquisition (price, vendor, date, who negotiated and signed, any commission); City agreements, land contributions, and payments for Pleasantvale and Now Canada (or successor names) housing projects the City Manager has publicly cited (counterparties, amounts, dates); the City Manager’s expense claims and supporting receipts line-by-line for 2023–2026 (not just the SOFI totals); and any conflict or recusal notes from Doug Gilchrist on the rail or housing files.

Why it matters and what it could show: Gilchrist was involved in the earlier CN Rail corridor acquisition that became the Okanagan Rail Trail. The City has also contributed to affordable housing projects such as Pleasantvale. The request seeks the underlying deal documents and full expense backup rather than summary totals. Possible issues include undisclosed commissions or side arrangements on land deals, incomplete public accounting of City contributions to housing projects he has promoted, or expense claims that lack proper documentation or contain items that raise questions about public purpose. Line-by-line receipts matter because aggregate SOFI numbers do not show what was claimed or approved.

These requests are ordinary tools citizens use when high-level public reports raise questions about how large sums of public money and land are handled. The seriousness comes from the combination of rapid compensation growth for the top unelected official, the City Manager’s background in real estate, a household connection to a local realtor, a major closed or low-transparency land purchase from a private developer that then continued managing the assets, and the City’s legal duty to produce the records (or properly refuse them) on a fixed timeline. Delayed or incomplete responses leave the public without the documents needed to evaluate whether ordinary rules on conflicts, authorization, and value were followed.

This is the complete factual record of the FOI interactions and the content of the releases as established from the materials in this conversation.

The external firm is Korn Ferry. They produce the market surveys the City uses for management pay. Those survey pages are almost entirely blacked out in the package.

On the City side, the visible record shows Stu Leatherdale (General Manager, People and Protective Services) sending the comparator table to the Audit Committee on November 6, 2023. Leatherdale’s department handles the exempt/management pay-band process and the surveys.

The Audit Committee is the Council body that reviews the City Manager’s performance and the management pay policy before it goes to full Council. In the 2023 open minutes that appear in the package, the members listed as present for related work are Mayor Tom Dyas, Councillor Ron Cannan, and Councillor Luke Stack.

Those are the names attached to the process. The actual closed-meeting votes and the full Korn Ferry numbers remain redacted.

City of Kelowna FOI Response on City Manager Compensation

The City of Kelowna released an 80-page package in response to an FOI request for Doug Gilchrist’s employment contract, pay-band policy, Korn Ferry market surveys, closed-meeting records related to his compensation, and payroll authorizations. The City first demanded a $2,000 deposit before it would process the request. Once the records were produced, large portions of the package were blacked out under multiple sections of the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act.

The 2018 employment contract that appears in the package starts Gilchrist at $247,487 per year plus a $500 monthly vehicle allowance. Internal HR emails on pages 78–80 of the same package list the successive authorized increases that followed: $324,253 in 2023 (with the vehicle allowance raised to $870 a month), $341,158 in 2024, and $358,251.68 in 2025. Those internal emails were not previously public. The City blacked out almost the entire Korn Ferry market-survey section and the closed-meeting records that were supposed to contain the justification for the increases, while leaving the internal instructions that implemented the higher numbers fully readable.

Open council minutes included in the package show when meetings were closed under the Community Charter for items that included the City Manager Performance Review. The minutes list who was present. The closed-meeting agendas also list the performance-review item. The actual closed-meeting notes, the motion, the vote count, and any record of who supported or opposed the increases are blacked out. A majority of those present is required to pass a resolution. The package does not show whether the vote was 5-4, 6-3, 7-2, or any other split.

The external firm that produced the market surveys is Korn Ferry. On the City side, the visible record shows Stu Leatherdale (General Manager, People and Protective Services) sending comparator information to the Audit Committee. The Audit Committee is the Council body that reviews the City Manager’s performance and the management pay policy before it goes to full Council. The package does not show the full survey results or the closed-meeting discussion that applied them.

The public already knew the final totals that appear in the City’s yearly SOFI reports. What the FOI package adds is the City’s own internal paper trail that authorized the intermediate steps, set against the redacted justification documents. The raises are visible in the City’s own words. The reasons remain hidden. The vote remains hidden. That is the record the City released.

Laura Bentley: Kelowna Clerk Deflecting and obstructing production of documents. 

LIKE OUR WORK?